"The drb sustains a level of commentary on Irish and international matters that no other journal in Ireland and few elsewhere can reach. It deserves all the support that can be given it." X
Space to Think, a new book celebrating ten years of the Dublin Review of Books More Information 

Irish women in medicine, c.1880s–1920s

Origins, education and careers
Laura Kelly
Publisher
Manchester University Press
Price
£60
ISBN
9780719088353


EXTRACT COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL

From the Introduction

My mother had serious illnesses for nearly a year and i nursed her and when she recovered to some extent (always an invalid) I decided to take up medicine -the school of the College of Surgeons was just opened to women when I began medicine in the autumn of 1887 (Victoria's 50 year Jubilee) at the (mixed) school and the College and qualified in 1891....
Emily Winifred Dickson

Emily Winifred Dickson, from Dungannon, Co. Tyrone, enrolled at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland at the age of twenty-one. With her father's encouragement, she had decided that she wanted to pursue a medical education. She had originally faced discouragement in her pursuit of admission to university. An application to Trinity College Dublin had been accepted with the support of the medical faculty, but was ultimately rejected due to opposition from the theologians of the university. Dickson was one of the earliest of 759 women who matriculated in medicine at Irish institutions between 1885 and 1922. Of these 759 women, 452 went on to qualify with medical degrees or licences. Certainly, Dickson was one of the pioneering women doctors of her generation and exceptional in terms of her ability and university career. However, she was typical of the women medical graduates of her generation and the next, in terms of the challenges she faced. In spite of these challenges, Dickson seems to have found herself readily accepted in the Irish medical profession in her early career and gained support from the medical hierarchy, in a surprising contrast to the received view of the Irish medical profession in the period as depicted by F. O. C. Meenan, in his history of the Catholic University School of Medicine:

There is no reason to suppose that aspiring women doctors found conditions more favourable in Ireland. They met the same determined opposition and prejudice from the medical establishment.2

Likewise, more recently, Irene Finn has argued that the Irish medical profession, with the exception of the King and Queen's College of Physicians of Ireland (KQCPI), held a hostile view towards women in medicine.31 will argue against these ideas by showing that Irish university authorities and members of the medical hierarchy in Ireland possessed a positive attitude towards women in the medical profession. Moreover, I consider the history of women in the medical profession in Ireland as being crucial to under­standing the history of women in the medical profession in Britain. Up until 1886, the KQCPI played a virtually unique role in the qualification of women doctors in Britain and Ireland, with forty-eight of the first fifty women who were registered in Britain as qualified medical practitioners before this year taking their examinations at the KQCPI.4 It is notable that Irish universities and hospitals opened their doors to women medical students earlier than their British counterparts, which is somewhat surprising considering that Ireland was at this time part of the United Kingdom and one might have expected similar trends.

The social, cultural and political context
The period within which this book is set was one of vast social, cultural and political change in Ireland. The beginning of the nineteenth century opened with the Act of Union, passed in 1800 and coming into effect in January 1801. The act united Ireland with Britain under one parliament, with all Irish MPs now sitting in Westminster. Up until 1922, with the passing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty which followed the Irish War of Independence, Ireland was ruled by Britain. The 1840s to 1850s witnessed increasing agitation from Catholics, with the Repeal of the Union movement led by Daniel O'Connell in the 1830s and 1840s, and the establishment of the Irish Republican Brotherhood in 1858, which staged a failed rising in 1867. In 1873 Isaac Butt's Home Rule Party was established to seek the restora­tion of the Irish parliament. What followed was a politically turbulent fifty years. Charles Stewart Parnell assumed leadership of the Home Rule Party in 1880 and there were two failed attempts to pass Home Rule Bills in 1886 and 1893, under Prime Minister William Gladstone. The year 1886 also saw the establishment of the Unionist Party, which organised itself against Home Rule from the mid-i88os and into the early twentieth century. From the 1880s until 1922, successive British governments implemented a policy of 'constructive Unionism', for instance through the establishment of the Congested Districts Board in 1891, which poured money and expertise into 'congested' and poor areas in the west of Ireland, while the Department of Agriculture and Technical Instruction was set up in order to improve agricultural performance and profits.5

Meanwhile, the 1880s and 1890s witnessed the birth of the Gaelic revival through the establishment of the Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA), which revived interest in Irish sports, and the Gaelic League, which promoted the Irish language. The Irish Literary Revival, which began in the 1890s, led by Anglo-Irish writers such as W. B. Yeats and Lady Gregory, also fostered nationalism and Irish identity. The Home Rule Party split in 1890 after the scandal over the divorce case of its leader, Parnell. In 1898 the Local Government Act set up county councils and urban district councils, and women's representation increased at local level. In 1900, the Home Rule Party reunited under the leadership of John Redmond, and Home Rule was passed by the British parliament in 1914 but its implementation was postponed until after the First World War. Cumann na nGaedheal, a nationalist non-violent organisation, was founded by Arthur Griffith in 1900, with women accepted as equal members.

The decade from 1912 to 1922 was increasingly turbulent. The year 1912 saw the establishment of the Ulster Volunteers, a militia to support the Ulster Unionists, led by Edward Carson. The Irish Labour Party (full title Irish Trade Union Congress and Labour Party) was also established in this year; the famous Dublin Lock-Out, where members of the Irish Transport and General Workers Union were locked out of their workplaces, occurred the following year. The Irish Citizen Army was founded following the Lock-Out and in 1914 the Irish Volunteers, with its female auxiliary group Cumann na mBan, was formed. The outbreak of the First World War caused huge divisions in Irish nationalism, with the majority of Volunteers, calling themselves the National Volunteers, supporting John Redmond's call to fight with Britain, while a minority, retaining the name Irish Volunteers, under the leadership of Eoin MacNeill, refused to fight.7